To quote Monty Python... "welcome to the middle of the album". Ironically I had originally planned to open the album with this track, but in the last year or so I got cold feet. Why? Whilst I love this track, it is a slow burner and doesn't have the same instant in-yer-face energy as But I Really Want To, so it got pushed back to the middle.
I Don't Know Why You Went Away is melancholy pop with a little cleverness. It is an exercise in how to develop a song, with a lot of subtle arrangement changes that I'm very proud of.
Unusually I can quote the exact date when this song was written; 29th July 1994 fast approaching midnight. It was my parents 25th wedding anniversary a major party and significant in several ways. Firstly I would get to see a girl who I long carried a torch for again, at the time I was a naive 16 year old though and there was a self realisation that despite us being the same age she was way out of my league. The long held dream was shattered. when I got back in around midnight I had this urge to just play something on the guitar... and hit the opening riff. Style wise the rhythm pattern is very different for me, I think this was partly due to the influence of my friend Neil who was very into the indie group Suede and lots of synchopated (off beat) rhythms. The lyrics tumbled out of my head from my state of mind; I do have memories of this being the first mildly low period.
The 29th July 1994 was also significant for another reason, it was the last time I saw my Dad's former workmate and my old mentor John Jackson. The last track of this album is dedicated to the memory of John Jackson because he sadly died of a heart attack just over three weeks after my parents 25th wedding anniversary.
I Don't Know Why I'm getting ahead of myself, but I'd better get back to this track..!
As per usual this was demo'ed on my original four track tape deck. As it was the planned opener it was one of the first tunes I tackled. I had a lot of fun playing around with the electric guitar and wrote the main riff. Now I am mostly known for playing acoustic folk songs locally, so to kick off my first 'proper' recording with an acoustic guitar and then hit people over the heard with a very LOUD electric part (a WHAM moment) appealed to my sense of humour. It's in-yer face . :-)
Then what to do about the bass line..? Erm I was very new to bass again so I decided to double up the guitar riff. Although my mischievous sense of humour was still there, by introducing the bass half way through a verse. It's unexpected as normally bass is introduced at the begining of a verse/chorus, not half way through! Around this time I noticed that there was no variety to the chord sequence, despite struggling to write at the time I found jotting down a middle eight surprisingly easy and fun. That's why it changes suddenly giving the song an extra kick.
By the late 90's I had produced a test EP that opened with this track, but also featured Alice, Forgive Me (a quirky instrumental and a tongue in cheek reference to a girl at college who didn't like my music), But I Really Want To and the original instrumental version of Beverley (which would go on to be merge with another instrumental and become a live Acoustic Moods highlight). It is ironic that out of the EP's I did on both occassions track 3 (But I Really Want To and Who We Are) were generally regarded as stronger...
When it came to using the computer to re-record my song, this one was eagerly anticipated but it turned into something of a nightmare! I lost count of how many hours this was worked, reworked messed about with!
Let's start at the begining. Dan tapped out the drum pattern based on my guitar riff (that man is a genuis), however originally we were using natural sounding drums. I wanted to use something very Phil Collins late Genesis style with an interesting melodic but clearly synthetic Roland drum machine, like Dreaming While You Sleep or Fading Lights both from the We Can't Dance album. So off I went, spent money on modern samples of the synthetic Roland drums then fiddled with Dan's pattern. Initially he was completely aghast at what I had done and his jaw hit the floor! We had our first - erm - creative disagreement (!) but again all credit to Dan's talent. It became a very productive evening, whilst I may have stomped my feet insisting on the Roland Drum machine, Dan was an expert at using this creative disagreement to improve the song.
I would cite this as example on why Dan is an awesome musician to work with, even when he doesn't agree with the direction of a song he is still able to take an idea and improve it significantly. I am very, very lucky to work with him.
This is another song where I play a lot of the live intruments, almost all the live guitars are me jamming; I had a great deal of fun. However for the guitar solo my mind was a blank so I asked my friend Neil. As ever he produced the goods in spades with an awesome solo, we had a ball recording it bouncing of each other and it was another fun night with us cracking jokes. I do remember Neil commented that he 'slipped a few Suede-isms in', quite appropriate given that the tune was inspired by Suede!
The drums however are heavy Phil Collins. Now when Neil is doing his thing, the spotlight rightly falls on his awesome solo. Listen closely to the drums though. Recognise the pattern? It's a tweaked version of a very famous drum fill. So famous I can almost feel it in the air tonight.
Whoops.
How did that happen? ;-)
Surprisingly, there's still more twists and turns with this tune! The lead vocals were me from 2003 ish. It on inferior equipment and almost lost, but it just 'felt right'. Depressed but not raging anger as a few friends expected. Just edgy, not shouty. It's also why I put some effects on there to distort the voice, but it's supposed to represent a state of mind teetering on the edge of depression.
Listen closely as well and you can hear some backing harmonies from both Dan (who blends beautifully) and Chris (who cuts through any mix!). Jim Murphy worked crazy hours with me getting the mix on this one right, not easy given the amount of things going on! For the last thirty seconds of the song I had a clear idea of hitting the bass drum more often (love that fill) and stopping suddenly. The looped copy of my voice was a cheery on top though up by Dan.
Judging by the length of this post alone, you can get the impression that a lot got crammed into this song!